Skip to Main Content

CHEM 4691 - Capstone Research I

Evaluation of Information Sources

Just because you see it in print or on your computer screen, do not assume it is accurate or reliable! To evaluate the credibility of an information source, these are the several key aspects to consider:

  • Currency
  • Relevance
  • Authority
  • Accuracy
  • Purpose

The following tables provide a framework for investigating these aspects of an information source, no matter it is an article in a journal, newspaper, book, website, or government document. However, not all questions will apply in all situations. These questions are intended to help you think critically about different information sources.

Currency:

Questions Answers
When was it published? Do you need current information?

Topics requiring the most up-to-date information may include:

  • Science
  • Technology
  • Current events
Has the source been revised or updated in a subsequent version? Use PowerSearch or Google for more recent editions. 

Relevance:

Questions Answers

Does the source provide information that is related to the main topic or theme of your research?

 Read the abstract, introduction, and conclusion of the source. Additionally, you can look for keywords and phrases that are related to your topic, and see if they appear in the source.

Authority:

Questions Answers

Who is the author?

What are the author's credentials/qualifications?

  • Institutional affiliation (where does the author work?)
  • Previous publication
  • Relevant university degree
  • Relevant field or employment experience

 

 Look in these tools for information about the author:
  • Search for the institution/organization website
  • Author's home page
  • Article indexes (e.g. Scopus) and Library PowerSearch for other works published by the author
What is the author's reputation among his/her peers? 
  • Cited in articles, books or bibliographies on the topic
  • Mentioned in your textbook or by your professor

Use the citation indexes database (Web of Science) to find articles citing your author
Who is the publisher?
  • Commercial, trade, institutional, etc
  • Editorial board
  • Mission, values and goals
  • Specialization
  • Known for quality and/or scholarly publication
  • Search for the publisher's Web site
  • Look for editorial guidelines (e.g. Elsevier)

Accuracy:

Questions Answers

Is the information logical, well-organized and supported by evidence? 

Is it free from errors (both content errors and spelling/grammar errors)?
  • Look at the headings to indicate structure
  • Read carefully for errors
  • Look for claims supported by evidence
  • Verify facts and statistics with other reliable sources

Do you think there is enough evidence offered? Is the coverage comprehensive?

Is it consistent with other information? Does it confirm what you know or have read about in other sources?

 Looking at the list of references in the source is an excellent way of not only understanding a work's coverage but also finding other excellent sources of research.
Does the information appear to be valid and well-researched?
  • Reasonable assumptions and conclusions
  • Arguments and conclusions supported by evidence
  • Opposing points of view addressed
  • Authoritative sources cited

Purpose:

Questions Answers
Does the author state the goals for his/her work? In other words, what is the publication purpose?
  • Inform, explain, educate
  • Advocate, opinions
  • Persuade or dissuade
  • Sell a product or service
 Read the foreword, preface, abstract, introduction and conclusion.
Does the author exhibit a particular bias?
  • Commitment to a point of view
  • Acknowledgment of bias
  • Presentation of facts and arguments for both sides of a controversial issue
  • Twisted interpretation of data
  • Use of sensational words

Examine the work for

  • Arguments or supporting facts
  • Inflammatory language
  • Propaganda
  • Author's arguments or supporting facts
  • Author's conclusions
© HKUST Library, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology. All Rights Reserved.